Do I play better than a 7th grader?


The problem: I don’t know how well I play, objectively speaking.

The solution: Ask an expert: Emily aka the Rebel Music Teacher.


It’s been almost 25 years since I started playing so I was delighted to discover my old Rubank book among my etude books. I thought - maybe I can handle this? Maybe playing exercises from the Rubank book will allow me to perform a self-assessment? Maybe I can play better than a 7th grader?


This book didn’t help me determine whether or not I play better than a 7th grader for a few reasons. First, there are no metronome markings so it’s hard to know if I am playing the exercises proficiently. In terms of music theory it’s far too elementary because I can count sixteenth notes and I know the difference between a slur and a tie. It’s been a fun book for sight-reading but to know how well I play, I will need to play for someone else (gulp).


Enter Emily, aka, the Rebel Music Teacher. Emily is a music educator, blogger and parent. She has been a music teacher for over a decade and most of her career has been as a middle school band director. She is also an old college friend of mine who performed with me at the apex of my flute-playing abilities. She knows how good I was - what will she think of my playing now? What will she think of me now?


Emily and I met on Facetime and she had a lot to say, especially about 7th graders and 7th grade. According to Emily, 7th grade is a very hard time,  “There’s a wide range (of abilities); (7th grade), it’s like the nadir of middle school...there’s a wide variety.”


First I played a D-major scale from Taffanel Exercise 4 knowing full-well that 7th graders don’t play T&G exercises. Immediately Emily said “D-major is not considered one of the middle school scales.” Emily teaches in Florida and in the Sunshine State middle schoolers are expected to play F, B-flat, E-flat, A-flat, D-flat, C, and G. These are the keys for all instruments and these keys were selected as those are common keys in band literature.


I then played Blue Bells of Scotland from the Rubank book (below). According to Emily, my ease playing high D was a dead giveaway that I am not a 7th grader,  “Band directors don’t put a lot of emphasis on 6th grade flutes working on their high notes. When they (7th graders) get to playing more advanced literature they’re like, ‘Oh, I have to play high notes now.’”

Peterson, A.C.. Rubank Elementary Method for Flute. Milwaukee: Hal Leonard, 1934.


Emily’s verdict: “I think you sound much better than a 7th grader...You sound at least like a 10th grade level.”


I’m clearly not a 7th nor a 10th grader. I’m in my thirties and I have a degree in music although I am out of practice. Emily could hear that too, “I think you sound really good...you still got your vibrato working. It’s clear you’ve had that for a really long time...You can tell you are not at the level you once were but you’ve been there.” By “there” Emily means the level of proficiency I had when I was in music school and getting ready to be a professional flute player. 


As supportive as Emily was, I couldn’t help but feel sad after our call. How do I get back “there” when I only have 15 minutes a day to practice? How do I get back “there” when it’s not safe to meet with other musicians to play in ensembles? I don’t know how I will get back “there” but unlike a 7th grader or 10th grader I get to decide what scales I need to practice, what solos I want to play, and how much I should be practicing a day. For the first time in my life my flute-playing is not being held to anyone else’s expectations or standards. I think that’s enough to inspire me to keep playing for now.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Where the hell is my low register?!?!?

Image
  Where the hell is my low register?!?!? The problem: I can’t produce a note below F4. The solution: Start in the middle register and work my way down. As a flutist, I had a secret weapon: a loud, clear sonorous low register. After over a decade sabbatical, It was gone (sigh). How do I get it back? How do you produce sounds that just aren’t there? I tried harmonics starting on the low register. But the same problem: how do you leverage a sound that isn’t there? Then I realized what I need to do: Play what is actually there. I started in the middle register and worked my way down . Set my metronome down to 60 bpm I set my metronome to 60 bpm. And started at C5 and slurred down an octave then back up. I found that this exercise gave me a starting point. Rather than searching for pitches that aren’t there, I could play the notes that were accessible to me then slur down an octave to find the low register again. This exercise was my warm for months and it was also a way for me to ...
Read more

Ear training with Kids Songs

Image
  The problem: I don’t know what to play. All of my sheet music is too hard because I haven’t practiced in years and practicing scales is essential but it gets boring fast. The solution:  Play melodies from children’s songs and nursery rhymes by ear. It’s ear training while playing actual music. When I had kids, I had no idea how my life would change. I simply didn’t know what I didn’t know. I mention in my introduction that I no longer had time to practice post-career-and-kids but after becoming a parent I started singing all off the time. ALL of the time. I sang my babies to sleep. I sang to help them calm down from a tantrum. We sang as a family in the car. My kids and I sang at library story time. We sang in the bath. We sang while watching Sesame Street. And when I lay in bed too exhausted to wake up in the morning I hear my daughter singing the songs I sing to her. When I picked up my flute again a few months ago I didn’t actually know what to play other than scales...
Read more

So MUCH to play, so little time

  So MUCH to play, so little time The problem: I have no meaningful amount of time to practice. The solution: I redefined “meaningful amount of time” and reduced my desired practice time from 1 hour on days-when-I-could-maybe-get-the-time-to-practice to 15 minutes on weekdays.  I recently organized my sheet music and etude books and finally created a dedicated practice space in my tiny, urban house. As I was alphabetizing my scores and etude books I thought about the literally thousands of hours I spent perfecting my craft of flute playing and suddenly felt angry - “Who the hell has the time to practice scales and arpeggios for hours on end?!?!” I screamed. Certainly no one with caring responsibilities. Definitely not a mother with two young kids. I don’t have time to be a flute player, I thought. I felt defeated. I didn’t practice for a few days. Then I got an idea and I said to myself, "Put practice on your calendar: 15 minutes a day. You know you will do it." Anyone who kn...
Read more